Independent site. Not the official Pat Finucane Review, the UK Government, the Finucane family or any inquiry. The official 2012 report is published on GOV.UK.

Finucane Case Reviewan independent guide

Law & the legal profession

What does Article 2 of the ECHR require from an investigation into a death?

Short answer

Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights requires states to hold an effective official investigation into certain deaths, which courts have said must be independent, adequate, prompt, open to public scrutiny and involve the family of the person who died.

Key takeaways

  • Article 2 protects the right to life and also carries a procedural duty to investigate certain deaths.
  • The investigation must be started by the state itself, without waiting for the family to complain.
  • Courts look at independence, adequacy, promptness, public scrutiny and involvement of the next of kin.
  • In the UK, the Human Rights Act 1998 makes Convention rights enforceable in domestic courts.
  • The duty is about the process; it does not guarantee a particular result such as a prosecution.

Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights is usually summed up as "the right to life." Much of the legal argument about deaths in the UK, especially deaths connected to the state, turns on a less obvious part of it: the duty to investigate. This explainer sets out what that duty is and how courts test it. It is general information, not legal advice.

What does Article 2 say?

Article 2 says that everyone's right to life shall be protected by law, and it allows deprivation of life only in narrow circumstances where force was absolutely necessary.

The text is short. It lists the situations where a use of force resulting in death is not a breach: defending someone from unlawful violence, effecting a lawful arrest or preventing escape, and lawfully quelling a riot or insurrection. In each case the force must be "absolutely necessary," a stricter test than ordinary reasonableness.

The words "shall be protected by law" do a lot of work. The European Court of Human Rights has read them, together with the general duty in Article 1 to secure Convention rights, as requiring the state to investigate certain deaths.

When does the duty to investigate arise?

The duty arises when a person has been killed by state agents using force, and it can also arise in other cases where the state may bear responsibility for a death.

The core case is a death caused by police, soldiers or other agents of the state. The European Court has also applied the duty to deaths in custody, to some deaths where the authorities may have failed to protect a person from a known risk, and to some deaths in state-run settings such as prisons.

Once the duty arises, the state must act on its own initiative. It cannot leave it to the family to start legal proceedings or take responsibility for the investigation.

What makes an investigation effective?

Courts ask whether the investigation was independent, adequate, prompt, open to public scrutiny and involved the next of kin to the extent needed to protect their legitimate interests.

Requirement What courts look for
Independence Investigators not hierarchically or institutionally connected to those implicated, and independent in practice
Adequacy Capable of establishing the facts and, where appropriate, identifying and punishing those responsible; reasonable steps taken to secure evidence
Promptness Begun quickly and pursued with reasonable expedition
Public scrutiny Enough openness to secure accountability in practice as well as in theory
Next of kin The family involved to the extent necessary to safeguard their legitimate interests

These standards come from the European Court's case law rather than the text of the Convention. The Court's Guide on Article 2 collects the leading judgments, including several cases brought against the United Kingdom about deaths in Northern Ireland.

Is it about the outcome or the process?

The duty concerns the process: an investigation must be capable of finding the facts and identifying those responsible, but it does not have to produce a particular outcome.

Courts call this an obligation of means, not of result. An investigation can meet the standard even if nobody is charged. It can also fall short even if it reaches a conclusion, for example if key evidence was never gathered or the investigators were not independent.

That distinction explains why litigation about Article 2 often focuses on how an investigation was run, rather than on who was to blame for the death itself.

How does the duty apply in UK law?

The Human Rights Act 1998 makes Convention rights, including Article 2, enforceable in UK courts and requires public authorities to act compatibly with them.

Under section 6 of the Act, it is unlawful for a public authority to act in a way that is incompatible with a Convention right. People can bring claims in UK courts rather than going straight to Strasbourg. UK courts must take account of European Court judgments, and they have developed their own case law on what an Article 2 investigation needs in particular settings, such as inquests.

The Act also affects how other legislation is read. Courts must interpret laws compatibly with Convention rights where possible, and higher courts can issue a declaration of incompatibility where that is not possible.

Which kinds of investigation can satisfy Article 2?

Inquests, criminal investigations, prosecutions, ombudsman investigations and public inquiries can all contribute, and courts look at the procedures in the round.

No single format is required. In the UK, an inquest is often the main vehicle, and the scope of an inquest may be widened so it can examine the broader circumstances of a death. Where an inquest cannot do that, for example because sensitive material cannot be heard, a public inquiry may be used instead. Our explainer on the Inquiries Act 2005 describes how statutory inquiries work.

Courts also consider whether earlier processes have already met the duty, and whether new evidence has revived it. This is why the same death can come back before the courts years later.

Where can you read more?

Start with the European Court's free Guide on Article 2, then read the text of the Human Rights Act 1998 and the relevant domestic judgments.

The Court's guide summarises the principles with case references, and each judgment can be read in full on the Court's HUDOC database. For how these questions have been argued in one long-running Northern Ireland case, see our frequently asked questions and the guide to the 2012 report. Other explainers on courts and lawyers are in Law & the legal profession.

Questions

Does Article 2 require a public inquiry?

Not in every case. The Convention requires an effective investigation, and the form can vary. Depending on the facts, an inquest, a police investigation, a prosecution or an inquiry, alone or together, may meet the duty.

Does the duty apply only to killings by the state?

No. The duty is strongest where state agents used lethal force, but courts have also applied it to other deaths, for example where the state may have failed to protect someone it knew to be at real and immediate risk.

Does Article 2 guarantee that someone will be prosecuted?

No. The obligation is one of means, not of result. The investigation must be capable of leading to the identification and, where appropriate, punishment of those responsible, but it need not end in a prosecution.

Where can I read the European Court's own summary of the case law?

The European Court of Human Rights publishes a free Guide on Article 2, updated regularly, that summarises the main judgments and principles.

Sources

  1. European Court of Human Rights: Guide on Article 2 of the Convention
  2. European Convention on Human Rights (full text)
  3. Human Rights Act 1998 (legislation.gov.uk)